Feedburner

Add to Google

Powered by Blogger

Friday, September 01, 2006

The Return of the $700 Hammer?

Some people call it being cheap. My dad used to refer to us as "thrifty Scotsmen." I have to admit I've really been stewing over this $150,000 traffic signal thing.

A little background. The other night at a meeting about the Westport Road and Genessee-Bell intersections, the City traffic engineer informed us that a pedestrian pushbutton traffic signal would cost somewhere in the range of a $150,000.

As I said in a previous post, I could have an entire house built for that. Granted, not the Taj Mahal but a house nonetheless. It would have a concrete basement that would require crews to come in, dig the hole, lay the forms and pour the concrete. It would have walls, requiring different crews to come in and construct them. It would have windows, a roof, plumbing, electrical and maybe even some carpet. I get all that, all those workers and materials for the same price it takes to put up one bolt-together mast arm with a traffic light hanging off of it?! Not to mention the builder would make a profit at the end of the day. How much profit is involved in one stoplight?

I think sometimes we lose track of the value of a dollar in our workplaces. I really think we lose that insight in government. For example at the Westport Road meeting I didn't really see too much of a reaction from anyone when the $150,000 figure was mentioned. I think people figure they don't know much about traffic signals so they'll just "leave it to the experts." What if the experts are getting ripped off? A quick Google on traffic signal cost revealed figures significantly lower than $150K. I even found a site detailing the cost savings of using LED instead of the traditional incandescent lights. To me, $150,000 is a LOT of money.

Government should always be looking to do things better and less expensively. I intend to pull cost out wherever I can. It's what I was taught to do. First by my "thrifty" father, then by my business school professors.

I think it's time to elect someone cheap, err... I mean thrifty. Like I always say, $150,000 here, $150,000 there, pretty soon you're talking real money!

Comments on "The Return of the $700 Hammer?"

 

DaveKCMO said ... (6:15 PM) : 

this place kills me! why not just have the pedestrian signal default to "walk" when the light turns? is that too difficult? if you're a pedestrian in this town, you're faced with knowing every single intersection and ped crossing individually because they certainly don't work the same way (if at all) from corner to corner. someone should force every council member to walk from downtown to the plaza and understand what it's like (it only takes an hour).

 

Anonymous said ... (8:47 PM) : 

A walk from downtown to the plaza would be a fun experiment for the KCMO council. I think the traffic engineers should tag along for a little research project.
However, we'd need to have plenty of MAST vehicles on stand-by. A five mile hike would cause a lot of damage to those commute loving elevator riders!

 

post a comment